The Politics of Skilled Immigration: Explaining the Ups and Downs of the US H-1B Visa Program - by CWP alumni Andrew Kennedy

Tuesday, May 22, 2018

The United States has long been a magnet for skilled immigrants, but its openness to these immigrants has varied considerably over time. Focusing on the H-1B visa program, this article explains why the program’s annual cap has risen and fallen from the mid-1990s to the present. Whereas recent studies of skilled immigration policy have focused on struggles between capital and labor, this article contends that US policy also reflects a struggle between capital and citizen groups — one that has changed considerably over the past two decades. The findings challenge recent work on skilled immigration and US immigration policy.

Andrew Kennedy

http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0197918318769312

First Published May 17, 2018 

References

  AFL-CIO. 2000. “Immigration.” http://www.aflcio.org/About/Exec-Council/EC-Statements/Immigration2Google Scholar
  American Competitiveness in the Twenty-First Century Act of 2000. 2000. Public Law No. 106–313. https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/PLAW-106publ313/pdf/PLAW-106publ313.pdfGoogle Scholar
  American Council on Education. 2013. “Higher Education Associations Strongly Endorse Senate Immigration Reform Bill.” https://www.aau.edu/sites/default/files/AAU%20Files/Key%20Issues/Budget%20%26%20Appropriations/FY17/Endorsement-Letter-S-744_6-26-13.pdfGoogle Scholar
  Asthana, A. 2006. “Immigrant Rights Groups Split over Senate Bill.” The Washington Post, July 28. Google Scholar
  Babington, C. 2006. “Immigration Bill Expected to Pass Senate This Week: Hastert May Block Version That Divides House GOP.” The Washington Post, May 23. Google Scholar
  Ball, M. 2013. “Immigration Reformers Are Winning August.” The Atlantic, August 21. Google Scholar
  Baumgartner, F. R., Berry, J. M., Hojnacki, M., Leech, B. L., Kimball, D. C.. 2009. Lobbying and Policy Change: Who Wins, Who Loses, and Why. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Google Scholar
  Belopotosky, D. 2004. “Efforts to Change Visa Law for Skilled Workers Gains Steam.” Technology Daily, October 1. Google Scholar
  Berry, J. M. 1999. The New Liberalism: The Rising Power of Citizen Groups. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press. Google Scholar
  Birkland, T. A. 1998. “Focusing Events, Mobilization, and Agenda Setting.” Journal of Public Policy 18(1):53–74. Google Scholar
  Boyle, M. 2013. “‘Tea Party Patriots’ Preps Activists for August Town Halls on Immigration, Obamacare.” Breitbart, August 5. Google Scholar
  Branigin, W. 1998. “Visa Deal for Computer Programmers Angers Labor Groups.” The Washington Post, September 27. Google Scholar
  Brustein, J. 2017. “The Secret Way Silicon Valley Uses the H-1B Program.” Bloomberg, June 6. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-06-06/silicon-valley-s-h-1b-secretGoogle Scholar
  Burghart, D., Zeskind, L.. 2012. “Beyond FAIR: The Decline of the Established Anti-Immigration Organizations and the Rise of Tea Party Nativism.” https://www.irehr.org/issue-areas/tea-party-nationalism/beyond-fair-reportGoogle Scholar
  Carrubba, C. J., Volden, C.. 2000. “Coalitional Politics and Logrolling in Legislative Institutions.” American Journal of Political Science 44(2):261–77. Google Scholar
  Cerna, L. 2009. “The Varieties of High-Skilled Immigration Policies: Coalitions and Policy Outputs in Advanced Industrial Countries.” Journal of European Public Policy 16(1):144–61. Google Scholar
  Cerna, L. 2014. “Attracting High-Skilled Immigrants: Policies in Comparative Perspective.” International Migration 52(3):69–84. Google Scholar
  Cerna, L. 2016. Immigration Policies and the Global Competition for Talent. London: Palgrave MacMillan. Google Scholar
  Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2005. 2004. Public Law No. 108-447. https://www.uscis.gov/ilink/docView/PUBLAW/HTML/PUBLAW/0-0-0-28233.htmlGoogle Scholar
  Costlow, T. 2000. “Senate Set to Vote This Week on Visa-Cap Bill; High Noon Approaches for H-1B Friends, Foes.” Electronic Engineering Times, October 2. Google Scholar
  DeParle, J. 2011. “The Anti-Immigration Crusader.” The New York Times, April 17. Google Scholar
  Facchini, G., Mayda, A. M., Mishra, P. 2011. “Do Interest Groups Affect US Immigration Policy?” Journal of International Economics 85(1):114–28. Google Scholar
  Facchini, G., Mayda, A. M. 2012. “Individual Attitudes Towards Skilled Migration: An Empirical Analysis Across Countries.” The World Economy 35(2):183–96. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9701.2011.01427.xGoogle Scholar
  Facchini, G., Willmann, G.. 2005. “The Political Economy of International Factor Mobility.” Journal of International Economics 67(1):201–19. Google Scholar
  Fiegerman, S. 2016. “Silicon Valley Throws Big Money at Clinton and Virtually Nothing at Trump.” http://money.cnn.com/2016/08/23/technology/hillary-clinton-tech-fundraisers/Google Scholar
  Fletcher, M. 2005. “Bush Immigration Plan Meets GOP Opposition; Lawmakers Resist Temporary-Worker Proposal.” The Washington Post, January 2. Google Scholar
  Freeman, G. P., Hill, D. K.. 2006. “Disaggregating Immigration Policy: The Politics of Skilled Labor Recruitment in the US.” Knowledge, Technology & Policy 19(3):7–26. Google Scholar
  Freeman, G. P., Tendler, S. M.. 2012. “Interest Group Politics and Immigration Policy.” In The Oxford Handbook of the Politics of International Migration, edited by Rosenblum, Marc, Tichenor, Daniel J., 324–44. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
  Fung, B. 2013. “Democrats’ Dilemma on High-Skilled Immigration Reform.” National Journal, March 6. Google Scholar
  Givens, T., Luedtke, A.. 2004. “The Politics of European Union Immigration Policy: Institutions, Salience, and Harmonization.” Policy Studies Journal 32(1):145–65. Google Scholar
  GovTrack.US. 2006. “S. 2611 (109th): Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act of 2006.” https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/109/s2611Google Scholar
  GovTrack.US. 2007. “S. 1348: Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act of 2007.” https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/110/s1348Google Scholar
  GovTrack.US. 2012. “H.R. 6429 (112th): STEM Jobs Act of 2012.” https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/112/hr6429Google Scholar
  GovTrack.US. 2013. “S. 744: Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act.” https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/113/s744Google Scholar
  Hainmueller, J., Hiscox, M. J.. 2010. “Attitudes Toward Highly Skilled and Low-Skilled Immigration: Evidence from a Survey Experiment.” American Political Science Review 104(1):61–84. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055409990372Google Scholar
  Hira, R. 2015. “Immigration Reforms Needed to Protect Skilled American Workers.” Hearing Before the US Senate Judiciary Committee, 114th Congress, March 17. Google Scholar
  Holyoke, T. T. 2013. “The Interest Group Effect on Citizen Contact with Congress.” Party Politics 19(6):925–44. Google ScholarSAGE Journals
  Howard, M. M. 2010. “The Impact of the Far Right on Citizenship Policy in Europe: Explaining Continuity and Change.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 36(5):735–51. Google Scholar
  Immigration Act of 1990. 1990. Public Law No. 101-649. https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/eoir/legacy/2009/03/04/IMMACT1990.pdfGoogle Scholar
  Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952. 1952. Public Law No. 82-414. https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/STATUTE-66/pdf/STATUTE-66-Pg163.pdfGoogle Scholar
  Information Technology Industry Council. 2013. “Technology Leaders Urge U.S. Senate to Approve Comprehensive Immigration Reform Legislation.” https://www.itic.org/news-events/news-releases/technology-leaders-urge-u-s-senate-to-approve-comprehensive-immigration-reform-legislationGoogle Scholar
  Institute for International Education. 2017. “Enrollment.” https://www.iie.org:443/Research-and-Insights/Open-Doors/Data/International-Students/EnrollmentGoogle Scholar
  Jones, T. 2006. “A Rising Issue.” St. Louis Journalism Review, May 1. Google Scholar
  Kerr, W. R., Lincoln, W. F.. 2010. “The Supply Side of Innovation: H-1B Visa Reforms and U.S. Ethnic Invention.” Journal of Labor Economics 28(3):473–508. Google Scholar
  Kiely, K. 2007. “Immigration Overhaul Crumbles in Senate Vote.” USA Today, June 29. Google Scholar
  Kollman, K. 1998. Outside Lobbying: Public Opinion and Interest Group Strategies. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Google Scholar
  Lawrence, J. 2013. “The Myth of Marco Rubio’s Immigration Problem.” National Journal, July 15. Google Scholar
  Lipton, E., Sengupta, S.. 2013. “Latest Product of Tech Firms: Immigrant Bill.” The New York Times, May 5. Google Scholar
  Lizza, R. 2013. “Getting to Maybe.” The New Yorker, June 24. Google Scholar
  Lowell, B. L., Martin, P.. 2012. “Managing the Dynamic Science and Engineering Labor Market in the United States.” International Migration Review 46(4):1005–12. Google Scholar
  Malhotra, N., Margalit, Y., Mo, C. H.. 2013. “Economic Explanations for Opposition to Immigration: Distinguishing between Prevalence and Conditional Impact.” American Journal of Political Science 57(2):391–410. Google Scholar
  McKinnon, J. D. 2005. “White House to Push for Revised Immigration Plan: Supporters Count on Help from Big Business to Sway Resistant Conservatives.” The Wall Street Journal, August 16. Google Scholar
  Milner, H. V., Tingley, D. H.. 2011. “The Economic and Political Influences on Different Dimensions of United States Immigration Policy.” http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2182086Google Scholar
  Milton, L. P. 2003. “An Identity Perspective on the Propensity of High-Tech Talent to Unionize.” Journal of Labor Research 24(1):31–53. Google Scholar
  Money, J., Falstrom, D. Z.. 2006. “Interests and Institutions in Skilled Migration: Comparing Flows in the IT and Nursing Sectors in the US.” Knowledge, Technology & Policy 19(3):44–63. Google Scholar
  Morrison, B. A. 2013. “Testimony.” Hearing Before the Committee on the Judiciary of the United States House of Representatives Subcommittee on Immigration Policy and Enforcement, March 5. Google Scholar
  Munro, N. 2010. “IT Industry, Hispanics Team up on Immigration.” National Journal, April 9. Google Scholar
  National Council of La Raza. 2011. “2011 Annual Report.” http://publications.nclr.org/handle/123456789/2Google Scholar
  National Foundation for American Policy. 2017. “H-1B Visas by the Numbers.” http://nfap.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/H-1B-Visas-by-the-Numbers-FY-2016.NFAP-Policy-Brief.June-2017.pdfGoogle Scholar
  O’Beirne, K. 2006. “Winning on Immigration.” The National Review, July 17. Google Scholar
  Olson, E. 2004. “Congress Raises Limit on Skilled-Work Visas.” International Herald Tribune, November 24. Google Scholar
  Omnibus Consolidated and Emergency Supplemental Appropriations Act for 1999. 1998. Public Law No. 105-277. https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/PLAW-105publ277/pdf/PLAW-105publ277.pdfGoogle Scholar
  Park, H. 2015. “How Outsourcing Companies Are Gaming the Visa System.” The New York Times, November 10. Google Scholar
  Peters, M. E. 2014. “Trade, Foreign Direct Investment, and Immigration Policy Making in the United States.” International Organization 68(4):811–44. Google Scholar
  Peterson, B. D., Pandya, S. S., Leblang, D.. 2014. “Doctors with Borders: Occupational Licensing as an Implicit Barrier to High Skill Migration.” Public Choice 160(1–2):45–63. Google Scholar
  Pietrucha, B. 1998. “Labor Challenges High Tech Job Shortage Claims.” Newsbytes News Network, March 19. Google Scholar
  PR Newswire. 1998. “FAIR Statement on the Pioneer Fund,” March 4. Google Scholar
  PR Newswire. 2007. “NumbersUSA Activists Squash Amnesty in Senate; Senate Rejects Cloture on Amnesty Bill 46–53,” June 28. Google Scholar
  Rodriguez, C. 2000. “Foreign Workers Bill Approved.” The Boston Globe, October 4. Google Scholar
  Rosenblum, M. R. 2011. US Immigration Policy Since 9/11: Understanding the Stalemate over Comprehensive Immigration Reform. Washington, DC: Migration Policy Institute. Google Scholar
  Ruiz, N. G., Wilson, J. H., Choudhury, S.. 2012. The Search for Skills: Demand for H-1B Immigrant Workers in U.S. Metropolitan Areas. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution. Google Scholar
  Shackelford, B., Jankowski, J.. 2016. “Information and Communications Technology Industries Account for $133 Billion of Business R&D Performance in the United States in 2013.” https://www.nsf.gov/statistics/2016/nsf16309/nsf16309.pdfGoogle Scholar
  Shesgreen, D. 2014. “Immigration Reform Critics Blast Boehner’s Remarks.” Gannett News Service, April 25. Google Scholar
  Simons, J. 1998. “Impasse on Bill to Boost Visas Persists Between Firms, U.S.” The Wall Street Journal, August 6. Google Scholar
  Tea Party Patriots. 2013a. “Senate Must Admit Full Costs of Immigration Bill before Passing Another ‘Train Wreck.’” http://www.teapartypatriots.org/all-issues/news/senate-must-admit-full-costs-of-immigration-bill-before-passing-another-train-wreck/Google Scholar
  Tea Party Patriots. 2013b. “Top 40 Reasons to Oppose the Gang of Eight Amnesty Bill.” https://www.teapartypatriots.org/top-40-reasons-to-oppose-the-gang-of-eight-amnesty-bill/Google Scholar
  Teitelbaum, M. S. 2014. Falling behind?: Boom, Bust, and the Global Race for Scientific Talent. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Google Scholar
  Tichenor, D. J. 2002. Dividing Lines: The Politics of Immigration Control in America. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Google Scholar
  Trump, D. J. 2017. “Presidential Executive Order on Buy American and Hire American.” https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2017/04/18/presidential-executive-order-buy-american-and-hire-americanGoogle Scholar
  Turnham, S. 2004. “Democrats: Bush Immigration Plan Not Enough.” http://edition.cnn.com/2004/ALLPOLITICS/01/07/elec04.immigration.dems/Google Scholar
  US Citizenship and Immigration Services. 2016. Characteristics of H-1B Specialty Occupation Workers: Fiscal Year 2015. Washington, DC: US Department of Homeland Security. Google Scholar
  US Immigration and Naturalization Service. 2002a. Report on Characteristics of Specialty Occupation Workers (H-1B): Fiscal Year 2000. Washington, DC: US Immigration and Naturalization Service. Google Scholar
  US Immigration and Naturalization Service. 2002b. Statistical Yearbook of the Immigration and Naturalization Service, 1999. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. Google Scholar
  US National Science Foundation. 2016. Science and Engineering Indicators 2016. Arlington, VA: Author. Google Scholar
  Valbrun, M., Thurm, S.. 2003. “Foreign Workers Will Soon Get Fewer U.S. Visas.” The Wall Street Journal, October 1. Google Scholar
  Wadhwa, V. 2012. The Immigrant Exodus: Why America Is Losing the Global Race to Capture Entrepreneurial Talent. Philadelphia: Wharton Digital Press. Google Scholar
  Walsten, P., Lynn Yang, J., Timberg, C.. 2013. “Facebook Flexes Political Muscle with Carve-Out in Immigration Bill.” Washington Post, April 16. Google Scholar
  Wasem, R. E. 2004. Immigration: Legislative Issues on Nonimmigrant Professional Specialty (H-1B) Workers. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service. Google Scholar
  Weisman, J. 2007. “Immigration Bill Dies in Senate.” The Washington Post, June 29. Google Scholar
  Weisman, J. 2014. “Boehner Doubts Immigration Bill Will Pass in 2014.” The New York Times, February 6. Google Scholar
  Weisman, J., Parker, A.. 2014. “Boehner Is Hit from the Right on Overhaul for Immigration.” The New York Times, February 7. Google Scholar
  Wingfield, N. 2017. “Cautious Optimism for Trump’s H-1B Plans.” The New York Times, April 20. Google Scholar
  Zengerle, J. 1998. “Silicon Smoothies.” The New Republic, June 8. Google Scholar
  Zuckerberg, M. 2013. “Mark Zuckerberg: Immigrants Are the Key to a Knowledge Economy.” The Washington Post, April 10. Google Scholar

 

Andrew Kennedy Photo